$1.4 million Florida Medicaid Overpayment Against Florida Home Health Agency Resolved for $0.

By Ralph Gaitan, Esq. | October 29, 2026 | Health Care Reimbursement, Audits & Appeals

Gaitan Law Group is pleased to report that a $1.4 million Medicaid overpayment demand against a Central Florida home health agency has been resolved for $0. The demand came from an AHCA Medicaid audit of services the agency billed in 2023 and 2024. On October 29, 2026, the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA), Office of Medicaid Program Integrity, closed the audit, 15 days after receiving our response to its Preliminary Audit Report.

AHCA Medicaid Audits Are Increasing in Florida

This result comes as scrutiny of Florida Medicaid providers reaches new levels. In March 2026, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) widened Medicaid fraud crackdown in Florida. CMS called Florida a hotspot for health care fraud and gave state officials 30 days to explain how they find and stop bad actors.

In June 2026, AHCA launched a statewide Medicaid integrity initiative. The initiative includes provider revalidation, expanded data analytics and claims monitoring, and enrollment moratoriums for certain high risk provider types. The results announced on October 6, 2026 include:

  • More than 220 providers terminated from Florida Medicaid for fraud, waste, or abuse, accounting for more than $230 million in Medicaid billing in 2025
  • More than 260 providers placed on payment restrictions or suspended from receiving payments
  • More than 400 provider site visits since January, focused on applied behavior analysis, durable medical equipment, and adult day care
  • More than 150 cases referred to the Attorney General’s Office over the past year

What Providers Are at Risk

All Florida Medicaid providers need to be prepared. Although these measures target fraud, the same tools reach providers who deliver legitimate care. For example, all active Florida Medicaid providers will need to revalidate their credentials and identities. Providers who fail to comply timely or do not meet program requirements will be removed from the Medicaid program.

Similarly, data analytics tools flag billing patterns, not intent. Under section 409.913, Florida Statutes, AHCA may review a sample of claims and apply the results to every claim paid during the audit period. A few claims that look unsupported on paper can become a demand large enough to threaten a provider’s business. That is exactly what our client faced.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an AHCA Medicaid audit?

An AHCA Medicaid audit is a review by the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration, Office of Medicaid Program Integrity, of whether a provider’s paid Medicaid claims were properly documented and billed. If the Agency finds claims it considers unsupported, it may seek repayment, extrapolate the error rate across the audit period, and impose sanctions.

What is a Preliminary Audit Report?

A Preliminary Audit Report (PAR) is AHCA’s initial written finding that a provider was overpaid. It lists the denied claims and the amount sought. The provider has a short window, often 15 days, to respond with records and explanations before AHCA issues a Final Audit Report.

How Gaitan Law Group Can Help With an AHCA Medicaid Audit

We help Florida Medicaid providers at every stage of an audit. When a provider receives any notice from AHCA, we take over the matter so that our clients can continue to provide valuable health care services to patients. Our firm helps helathcare providers with:

  • Records requests. Organizing and producing records the way the reviewer reads them, before any findings are made.
  • Preliminary Audit Reports. Securing extensions and the audit work papers, analyzing every denied claim, challenging extrapolation, and preparing a complete written response.
  • Final Audit Reports and hearings. Requesting an administrative hearing under Chapter 120, Florida Statutes, and representing you through the administrative law process.
  • Payment holds, suspensions, and terminations. Acting quickly to protect your cash flow and your Medicaid enrollment.
  • Audit readiness. Reviewing your documentation practices as part of a health care compliance program, before AHCA calls.

Related: read about our successful hospice Medicare overpayment appeal.

Facing a Medicaid or Medicare Audit?

Gaitan Law Group represents health care providers in Florida Medicaid and federal Medicare audits, overpayment appeals, and administrative proceedings. If you have received a records request, a Preliminary Audit Report, or a Final Audit Report from AHCA, call us at 786.440.8115 or contact us online. Learn more about our Medicare and Medicaid overpayment appeals and health care reimbursement audit services.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome; every audit depends on its own facts and records. This post is for general information and is not legal advice. Ralph Gaitan, Esq. is licensed to practice law in Florida. The hiring of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements.